Managing for Results

12. Evaluation Use

Does the state use program evaluations to improve results?

The state has improved results by using evaluation, program inventories, and cost-benefit analysis.

Minnesota

Leading Example

As a result of a 2015 Minnesota law, Minnesota Management and Budget (MMB) has developed numerous inventories of evidence-based programs, including in the areas of juvenile justice, criminal justice, adult and children’s mental health, substance use disorder, higher education, child welfare, public health, and education. MMB also maintains the Minnesota Inventory, a searchable clearinghouse of more than 730 programs operating in the state. As part of the inventory, the state developed a guide for using evidence in policymaking and evidence definitions to categorize interventions as proven effective, promising, theory based, or no effect. These definitions have been adopted by other agencies and are frequently included in state statute.

In 2021, Minnesota enacted legislation that requires recipients of state-funded pre-K-12 education grants to conduct an evidence-based evaluation. The legislation states: “each grant recipient​ must compile a report that describes the data that was collected and evaluate the effectiveness​ of the strategies.”

The Minnesota Board of Pharmacy and MMB partnered with The Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL) and a team of academics to test new messages designed to reduce dangerous co-prescribing of opioids with gabapentin and benzodiazepines. The evaluation randomly assigned prescribers to a range of messages (as well as a no message group) and are testing which is most effective. MMB also partnered with J-PAL and academics on a project to identify trusted messages and messengers to encourage Black and Hispanic communities to increase their rates of COVID-19 testing and vaccine uptake. The work also used a randomized control trial to test the right level of incentives to encourage COVID-19 vaccine uptake.

Issue Areas: Child Welfare, Criminal Justice, Economic Mobility, Education, Equity, Health, Workforce

Promising Examples

12 CA

California

12 CO

Colorado

12 CT

Connecticut

12 FL

Florida

12 NC

North Carolina

12 NJ

New Jersey

12 NM

New Mexico

12 OH

Ohio

12 OR

Oregon

12 PA

Pennsylvania

12 TN

Tennessee

12 TX

Texas

12 UT

Utah

12 VT

Vermont

12 WA

Washington